Original Imagine: Imagine being in love with Jeremy but dating Matt.
Reader Gender: Female.
Note: I thought this was really interesting so I decided to do it. I was actually really happy with how this came out, I was surprised how much I enjoyed not only writing it but that I ended up really liking it. Anyway, I hope you guys enjoy it.
There I was in between my lovely boyfriend Matt Donovan and the guy I’ve been in love with for years, Jeremy Gilbert. It was always hard to be around one or the other, but when they’re together it made it a whole lot worse. Matt has always been so wonderful the relationship would be perfect or close to perfect since there’s really no such thing, if I didn’t feel so strongly for his friend. It wasn’t that I didn’t like Matt, I truly did but my heart was always set on Jeremy. I thought I would’ve been able to move on after a while, but it hasn’t happened. I remember when Matt and I went on a double date, he was surprised to find out we already knew one another. If I had known they knew one another I would’ve kept my distance because being around Jeremy always confused me. It could be because my feelings have always been so strong, I never knew what to do about it. I never told anyone because talking about it only made it more real.